i saw it yesterday and i think it was "ok" till "good"
its also played as a theatrical musical at our local theatre and i missed alot of stuff from that show in the movie

the mood was fitting more to the story but less to the musical flair and i didnt enjoy the singing very much (except some particular parts where johnny depp gets a really nice voice)
but overall the singing just seemed pretty "dead" and "bored" to me, which was probably on purpose to let it fit into that grey style

i missed the funny joyful parts, especially in ms. lovett
also it was too bloody for my taste ^^"

"by the sea" was pretty cool though =)
had cool transistions and got funny (also i realized how i missed colors XD)

its to mention that i have seen the play before the movie and so already knew the whole plot
so~
i liked the play more and thats my opinion to that =)