damn. that dude was kinda a dick about it. it doesnt look like that bad of a game. He was bad at puzzles.... many times he bitched about things that were very easy to figure out.
not that it looks great. it could use some work making the themes match more, fixing the resolution, etc., but it still does not look awful. and it looks like it plays fine if the reviewer wasn't to *dur* to figure out the puzzles.