It just doesn't seem right to me for the developer(s) of crayon physics to receive an IGOTY award when their game is nothing new, nothing special, and nothing really interesting. I saw the video of the game on their website, it's not like they did anything revolutionary with the concept of "use physics and drawing to solve the puzzle!". If it was the first of its kind, then I can imagine it winning an award or two, or at least the respect of many players/developers. Otherwise, the only thing I see here is one of the first commercialized versions of a physics drawing game.

I suppose this is just boiling down to my personal opinion, but I'm sure there were better nominees that deserved the title of IGOTY.