Do you have the same issue without the shader?

1st one ist the best.

The problem appears with the Cartoon Shader, AND without it...

Can/will you post the model? (with texture but no need for shader)

Also, I preferr 3, but also think the black 'borders' need anti-aliasing
or maybe just thinning out a little.



[EDIT] Isnt this the same model that you had some wierd
dis-connected polys on its body somewhere before?

no.. i have redone the completely .. Set every vertex and polygon by hand...

2. its perfect not too much detail not too little detail

i´ll give the palyer the choice between the 2nd, 3rd and a more cel shaded 4rth way.

i think that´d be the best way ^^

I don't think that this is a good idea, IMO the game should have a fixed style.
This is your game, you are the creator, choose a style.

Thats true, nail down one artisitc approach, and
just continue with that.
Else you would be constantly unsure about the art, and
dont get the actual game done.

You know, i've played games where a different art style was an unlockable feature or cheat.Whats the difference if you allow the player to change it right away?