I may be alone on this one, and it's to be expected, but I look at graphics first. Regardless of what the game plays like, It has to look good before I touch it. In my opinion, I hate Borderlands and Borderlands 2 because of the cartoon graphics. We live in a world where realistic graphics are extremely possible, so I don't want to see 8 bit graphics (minecraft) on a console that is quite capable of producing decent HD or even normal resolution graphics.