I don't know why, but the big sites (with some exceptions) and paper magazines do mark Daemonica low.

However as far as I can tell we got also some more positive reviews in Germany (most of them being webzines though):

4Players 78%
GBase 6/10
PC games 60%
X zine Extrem gut
CNet.de Average
GameCaptain.de 68%
WithinGames.net 3/5

In America, according to gamerankings.com, we have average 73% (with about 25 reviews).

There's still a _lot_ to learn but I guess it's quite a good start