Dear friends,

We've got one more doc that was posted in another thread - sorry for that. I can't edit the old poll, so I have locked the thread so that you can vote here. Please don't forget to read "Dungeon Souls" as well and vote again.

As you might know, we are teaming up in order to create a community game. Several engine users have submitted their game design docs; please read them all and vote your favorite. I would really appreciate it if you would tell use why did you choose that specific game design doc.

Team members (or wannabe team members) please email me - george at acknex dot net - your forum name, your specialties (programming, level design, modeling, texture work, music, sound effects, etc) and the estimated number of hours per week that you can spend working at this project. If all goes well, we plan to turn this into a commercial product.

These are the links to the docs:
Me, Myself, and My Enemy
Broken Planet
Sorcerers
The Arcade Room
Mars Runs Red
Enemies
Slacer
Superku
Dungeon Souls

What is the best game idea? single choice
Me, Myself, and My Enemy	19%, 9 Votes
Broken Planet	2%, 1 Votes
Sorcerers	2%, 1 Votes
The Arcade Room	11%, 5 Votes
Mars Runs Red	4%, 2 Votes
Enemies	15%, 7 Votes
Slacer	9%, 4 Votes
Superku	32%, 15 Votes
Dungeon Souls	6%, 3 Votes
Total Votes: 47 Voting on this poll ends: 01/27/10 23:00

That is a hard decision...

I like Broken Planents, but slacers and superkus are good too

all entries have their nice points.

i also like the broken planets and slacer,voted for superku but i guess these 3 can be mixed somehow.

They're all nice, but I can choose only one vote.

Voted for Superku.

This is really a hard choice since all entries are of a different type and each one has a unique and original appeal.

If development time wouldn't matter my first choice would be Mars Runs Red: hidden ruins, caves of Mars, space-stations, primitive life forms... If these games were on a shelf in a store this is the game I would buy and play (...and Sorcerers ).
But, by taking everything into account, my choice is Blink & MMME: game concept can be casual(re-playable), 3D environment can be carefully reduced and time-shift based problems, puzzles & traps are very interesting and can be a great product-sellers.

My vote goes to Blink: Me, Myself and My Enemy.

I vote for Dungeon Souls.
It is easy to make, and can be as complex and popular as Spelunky is.

14215 Registered Users and 22 votes yet?

shame....

What is a shame? That people made fake accounts disfiguring the number of registered users? Or that a lot left the forum over the past decennia? Or that not everyone cares about this project? Or perhaps that not everyone has yet voted within 24 hours?

thats how it always is for these contests, plus its better not to vote than to just click on one without reading the docs

There is always a big silence during weekends. Lets see how this develops...
The numbers in the chart dont really show a sign for tons of fake accounts.