Why annual return of Z12 in v1.96 lower than previous version ?

Gamestudio Links

Zorro Links

Newest Posts

Data from CSV not parsed correctly
by EternallyCurious. 04/25/24 10:20

Trading Journey
by howardR. 04/24/24 20:04

M1 Oversampling
by Petra. 04/24/24 10:34

Zorro FIX plugin - Experimental
by flink. 04/21/24 07:12

Scripts not found
by juergen_wue. 04/20/24 18:51

zorro 64bit command line support
by 7th_zorro. 04/20/24 10:06

StartWeek not working as it should
by jcl. 04/20/24 08:38

folder management functions
by VoroneTZ. 04/17/24 06:52

AUM Magazine

Latest Screens

Who's Online Now

5 registered members (AndrewAMD, SBGuy, Petra, flink, 1 invisible), 699 guests, and 6 spiders.

Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod

Newest Members

Mega_Rod, EternallyCurious, howardR, 11honza11, ccorrea
19048 Registered Users

Print Thread

Rate Thread

Why annual return of Z12 in v1.96 lower than previous version ? #475398 12/06/18 10:15 12/06/18 10:15
Joined: May 2018 Posts: 4 3 B beannt OP Guest
beannt OP Guest B Joined: May 2018 Posts: 4 3	I have done some Z12 strategy tests, but the AR is very low only 78% compare to previous version, is there any difference in config between versions. WFA Test Z12 (TICKS) Simulated account AssetsICMarkets Bar period 4 hours (avg 338 min) Simulation period 2010-04-29..2018-10-27 (13213 bars) Test period 2013-08-22..2018-10-27 (8043 bars) Lookback period 500 bars (17 weeks) WFO test cycles 14 x 574 bars (19 weeks) Training cycles 15 x 5170 bars (178 weeks) Montecarlo cycles 200 Simulation mode Realistic ticks (slippage 5.0 sec) Gross win/loss 95772$ / -77667$ (+73218p) Virtual win/loss 101820$ / -83070$ Average profit 3495$/year, 291$/month, 13.44$/day Max drawdown -4422$ 24.4% (MAE -5179$ 28.6%) Total down time 76% (TAE 93%) Max down time 19 weeks from Apr 2015 Max open margin 1119$ Max open risk 364319$ Trade volume 16324075$ (3151635$/year) Transaction costs -1667$ spr, 38.44$ slp, -2840$ rol, -888$ com Capital required 4484$ Number of trades 4140 (800/year, 16/week, 4/day) Percent winning 49.2% Max win/loss 705$ / -1163$ Avg trade profit 4.37$ 17.7p (+190.1p / -149.4p) Avg trade slippage 0.0092840$ 0.0p (+2.5p / -2.3p) Avg trade bars 31 (+38 / -23) Max trade bars 431 (14 weeks) Time in market 1602% Max open trades 32 Max loss streak 24 (uncorrelated 13) Annual return 78% Profit factor 1.23 (PRR 1.18) Sharpe ratio 0.81 Kelly criterion 0.84 R2 coefficient 0.791 Ulcer index 11.0% Cycle performance 1.25 1.25 1.26 1.18 Confidence level AR DDMax Capital 10% 96% 3306 3635$ 20% 87% 3815 4022$ 30% 83% 4048 4200$ 40% 80% 4301 4393$ 50% 74% 4713 4706$ 60% 69% 5207 5083$ 70% 64% 5755 5499$ 80% 55% 6879 6355$ 90% 49% 7992 7202$ 95% 43% 9213 8131$ 100% 27% 15272 12742$ Portfolio analysis OptF ProF Win/Loss Wgt% Cycles AUD/USD avg .010 1.00 533/409 -2.6 XXXXXXXXXXXXX EUR/USD avg .035 1.34 1617/1223 95.2 XXXXXXXXXXXXX/ GBP/USD avg .029 1.42 888/900 74.1 XXXXXXXX/XXXX GER30 avg .023 1.43 376/408 55.3 XXXXXXXXXXXXXX NAS100 avg .008 2.52 158/96 73.4 /X/X/XXX////X/ SPX500 avg .003 1.06 108/137 4.5 XXX/X/// UK100 avg .004 1.58 62/71 17.8 XXXX/XXX/X/X US30 avg .011 1.20 726/1129 36.9 XXXXXXXXXXXXXX USD/CAD avg .044 1.32 1864/1876 92.8 XXXXXXXXXXXXXX USD/CHF avg .029 1.53 351/407 7.4 XXXXXXXXXXXX/X USD/JPY avg .006 1.45 277/300 17.5 X//X/XX/XXXXX XAG/USD avg .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. XAU/USD avg .005 1.12 130/308 2.8 XXXXXXXXXXXX A2 avg .010 1.41 398/275 85.5 XXXXXXXXXXXXXX BB avg .025 1.67 817/463 46.9 XXX/XXX/XXXX/ CT avg .021 1.70 493/405 80.4 XXXXXXXXXXXXXX CY avg .016 0.99 1214/925 -4.9 XXXXXXXXXXXXX ES avg .003 1.10 337/495 6.1 XXXXXXXXXXXXXX HP avg .013 1.18 1116/1057 53.2 XXXXXXXXXXXXXX HU avg .013 1.41 490/533 86.0 XXXXXXXXX/X/XX LP avg .007 1.09 277/596 2.8 XXXXXXXXXXXXXX VO avg .038 1.38 1948/2515 119.2 XXXXXXXXXXXXXX AUD/USD:A2 .061 1.39 160/104 63.7 .XXXXX/XXXXXX AUD/USD:A2:L .061 1.13 77/56 10.7 ..XX/X///X AUD/USD:A2:S .061 1.64 83/48 53.0 .X//X//XX// AUD/USD:CY .000 0.88 373/305 -66.3 XXX/XXXXXXXX AUD/USD:CY:L .000 0.61 160/169 -110.2 //XXX/X AUD/USD:CY:S .062 1.16 213/136 43.9 /////XX// EUR/USD:BB .131 1.58 400/218 15.1 /////////X/ EUR/USD:BB:L .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. EUR/USD:BB:S .131 1.58 400/218 15.1 /////////X/ EUR/USD:CT .143 2.15 78/40 14.2 .///X.X/XX// EUR/USD:CT:L .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. EUR/USD:CT:S .143 2.15 78/40 14.2 .///X.X/XX// EUR/USD:CY .101 1.40 492/335 37.2 XXX/XXXXXX/ EUR/USD:CY:L .089 1.22 242/186 11.3 /X.//X/// EUR/USD:CY:S .109 1.62 250/149 25.9 .X///XXXX// EUR/USD:HP .062 1.08 388/340 6.9 /XXXXXXXXXXX/ EUR/USD:HP:L .000 0.85 227/225 -8.1 /X\XX//X/ EUR/USD:HP:S .072 1.42 161/115 15.1 .//X/./// EUR/USD:VO .085 1.40 259/290 21.7 XXXXXXXXXXXXX/ EUR/USD:VO:L .085 1.58 135/141 15.5 X//XX//XX/ EUR/USD:VO:S .085 1.22 124/149 6.3 XX//X/XX/// GBP/USD:A2 .086 1.51 238/171 21.8 XXXXXXXX/XXXX GBP/USD:A2:L .061 1.03 109/94 0.5 X//XXX.X/X GBP/USD:A2:S .098 1.84 129/77 21.3 X//////// GBP/USD:BB .113 1.67 46/49 3.8 /.../..... GBP/USD:BB:L .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. GBP/USD:BB:S .113 1.67 46/49 3.8 /.../..... GBP/USD:CT .083 1.86 103/100 26.4 .XXXX/X/XX/ GBP/USD:CT:L .000 0.74 39/64 -4.1 .XXXX/X.XX. GBP/USD:CT:S .113 3.08 64/36 30.5 .X////./ GBP/USD:HP .000 0.98 198/195 -0.8 .X//XX/XX/ GBP/USD:HP:L .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. GBP/USD:HP:S .000 0.98 198/195 -0.8 .X//XX/XX/ GBP/USD:VO .147 1.43 303/385 22.9 XX/XXX/X/X// GBP/USD:VO:L .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. GBP/USD:VO:S .147 1.43 303/385 22.9 XX/XXX/X/X// GER30:BB .099 2.51 22/10 5.7 .X/..../X/... GER30:BB:L .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. GER30:BB:S .099 2.51 22/10 5.7 .X/..../X/... GER30:CT .062 1.64 44/41 13.0 X.XXXX//XX GER30:CT:L .061 2.32 19/14 9.3 ...X.//\ GER30:CT:S .067 1.28 25/27 3.7 X.X/X/.X/ GER30:ES .075 1.37 147/183 9.7 XXXXXXXXXXXXXX GER30:ES:L .101 2.07 85/82 12.7 X/X/XXX/XXX/ GER30:ES:S .000 0.78 62/101 -3.1 /XX/XXXXXXX GER30:HP .075 1.35 163/174 26.9 /XXX..XXXXXXX GER30:HP:L .092 1.88 83/88 28.6 .//...XXXX/X/ GER30:HP:S .000 0.96 80/86 -1.7 /XXX..//X/ NAS100:CT .078 2.35 60/24 21.1 /////////// NAS100:CT:L .078 2.35 60/24 21.1 /////////// NAS100:CT:S .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. NAS100:HU .081 2.60 98/72 52.3 /X////X////X/ NAS100:HU:L .081 2.60 98/72 52.3 /X////X////X/ NAS100:HU:S .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. SPX500:HU .061 1.06 108/137 4.5 XXX/X/// SPX500:HU:L .061 1.06 108/137 4.5 XXX/X/// SPX500:HU:S .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. UK100:HU .087 1.58 62/71 17.8 XXXX/XXX/X/X UK100:HU:L .087 1.58 62/71 17.8 XXXX/XXX/X/X UK100:HU:S .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. US30:BB .128 4.00 20/12 18.1 /./.X........ US30:BB:L .142 8.84 16/4 18.4 ..././........ US30:BB:S .000 0.93 4/8 -0.3 /........... US30:ES .000 0.90 190/312 -3.5 XX/XXXXXXXXXXX US30:ES:L .000 0.85 94/143 -2.3 /X//XXXXXXX/ US30:ES:S .000 0.94 96/169 -1.2 XX/XX/X/XX/XX US30:HU .000 0.95 98/149 -2.8 XXX/XXX//// US30:HU:L .000 0.95 98/149 -2.8 XXX/XXX//// US30:HU:S .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. US30:VO .061 1.27 418/656 25.2 /X//XXX////X US30:VO:L .061 1.27 418/656 25.2 /X//XXX////X US30:VO:S .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. USD/CAD:BB .100 1.13 240/109 3.1 //X.//////. USD/CAD:BB:L .092 1.13 240/109 3.1 //X.//////. USD/CAD:BB:S .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. USD/CAD:CT .090 1.25 152/141 6.3 XXXXXX/XXXX USD/CAD:CT:L .103 1.84 92/62 8.1 X//XX/XXX.X USD/CAD:CT:S .000 0.88 60/79 -1.9 XXXX////. USD/CAD:CY .079 1.40 349/285 24.2 XXXXX/X/XXX/ USD/CAD:CY:L .096 1.78 190/124 23.2 /X/X////// USD/CAD:CY:S .065 1.03 159/161 1.0 \X////X/ USD/CAD:HP .081 1.25 367/348 20.1 XXXXXXX/XXX/ USD/CAD:HP:L .112 1.51 210/150 17.9 XX/XX///X/ USD/CAD:HP:S .061 1.05 157/198 2.1 XXX/.X// USD/CAD:HU .110 1.78 124/104 14.2 X////XXX/X// USD/CAD:HU:L .110 1.78 124/104 14.2 X////XXX/X// USD/CAD:HU:S .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. USD/CAD:LP .000 0.87 63/142 -0.7 XXXX/X/X USD/CAD:LP:L .000 0.87 63/142 -0.7 XXXX/X/X USD/CAD:LP:S .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. USD/CAD:VO .071 1.33 569/747 25.8 XXXXXX/XXXXXXX USD/CAD:VO:L .093 1.52 304/357 17.9 X///.X/XXXXXXX USD/CAD:VO:S .061 1.19 265/390 7.9 XXX/X//XX USD/CHF:BB .070 1.28 89/65 1.1 //......../ USD/CHF:BB:L .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. USD/CHF:BB:S .070 1.28 89/65 1.1 //......../ USD/CHF:LP .284 1.28 84/146 0.8 X//XXXXXXX/ USD/CHF:LP:L .096 1.28 84/146 0.8 X//XXXXXXX/ USD/CHF:LP:S .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. USD/CHF:VO .367 1.76 178/196 5.5 ../X/X///X/X USD/CHF:VO:L .367 1.76 178/196 5.5 ../X/X///X/X USD/CHF:VO:S .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. USD/JPY:CT .000 0.95 56/59 -0.5 ///.X/XX/X USD/JPY:CT:L .000 0.95 56/59 -0.5 ///.X/XX/X USD/JPY:CT:S .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. USD/JPY:VO .111 1.67 221/241 18.0 X////XX/X/XXX USD/JPY:VO:L .111 1.67 221/241 18.0 X////XX/X/XXX USD/JPY:VO:S .000 ---- 0/0 0.0 .............. XAU/USD:LP .063 1.12 130/308 2.8 XXXXXXXXXXXX XAU/USD:LP:L .000 0.80 58/159 -2.4 XX/XX/X XAU/USD:LP:S .097 1.49 72/149 5.2 /X/X\XXXX/ Last edited by beannt; 12/07/18 03:39.

Re: Why annual return of Z12 in v1.96 lower than previous version ? [Re: beannt] #475423 12/07/18 13:42 12/07/18 13:42
Joined: Jul 2000 Posts: 27,982 Frankfurt jcl Chief Engineer
jcl Chief Engineer Joined: Jul 2000 Posts: 27,982 Frankfurt	The return of a strategy depends on the test period and the asset data, so it is different when any of them changes.

Re: Why annual return of Z12 in v1.96 lower than previous version ? [Re: jcl] #475444 12/10/18 07:08 12/10/18 07:08
Joined: May 2018 Posts: 4 3 B beannt OP Guest
beannt OP Guest B Joined: May 2018 Posts: 4 3	I have made clean a installation, re-download history data, use right Assets.csv for broker but the result is not better only 107%. What can I do to achieve the same result as 1.88 ? WFA Test Z12 (TICKS) Simulated account AssetsICMarkets Bar period 4 hours (avg 337 min) Simulation period 2010-04-29..2018-10-27 (13213 bars) Test period 2013-08-22..2018-10-27 (8043 bars) Lookback period 500 bars (17 weeks) WFO test cycles 14 x 574 bars (19 weeks) Training cycles 15 x 5170 bars (178 weeks) Montecarlo cycles 200 Simulation mode Realistic ticks (slippage 5.0 sec) Gross win/loss 114449$ / -92571$ (+64229p) Average profit 4224$/year, 352$/month, 16.25$/day Max drawdown -3685$ 16.8% (MAE -4897$ 22.4%) Total down time 67% (TAE 96%) Max down time 18 weeks from Aug 2017 Max open margin 1158$ Max open risk 6552$ Trade volume 16473674$ (3180518$/year) Transaction costs -1786$ spr, -3021$ slp, -3361$ rol, -874$ com Capital required 3962$ Number of trades 3737 (722/year, 14/week, 3/day) Percent winning 49.1% Max win/loss 844$ / -1134$ Avg trade profit 5.85$ 17.2p (+183.0p / -143.0p) Avg trade slippage -0.81$ -2.4p (+0.9p / -5.6p) Avg trade bars 47 (+59 / -36) Max trade bars 689 (23 weeks) Time in market 2224% Max open trades 35 Max loss streak 15 (uncorrelated 13) Annual return 107% Profit factor 1.24 (PRR 1.18) Sharpe ratio 0.94 Kelly criterion 0.83 R2 coefficient 0.787 Ulcer index 8.3% Cycle performance 1.26 1.27 1.24 1.17 Confidence level AR DDMax Capital 10% 126% 2896 3361$ 20% 119% 3135 3544$ 30% 111% 3464 3794$ 40% 106% 3708 3980$ 50% 102% 3937 4154$ 60% 95% 4313 4440$ 70% 89% 4728 4756$ 80% 82% 5257 5159$ 90% 69% 6485 6093$ 95% 62% 7454 6831$ 100% 38% 13245 11238$

Moderated by Petra