Gamestudio Links
Zorro Links
Newest Posts
error
by OptimusPrime
Yesterday at 22:10
Error message : Closing Order Quantity
by OptimusPrime
Yesterday at 22:07
Votes for future features
by ags
Yesterday at 19:19
New Zorro version 2.03
by brax
Yesterday at 11:20
Doubts about Detrend modes
by jcl
Yesterday at 08:40
Download all constituent stocks within Russel 1000
by jcl
Yesterday at 08:26
datafeed and broker are different, possible?
by jcl
Yesterday at 08:24
AUM Magazine
Latest Screens
Pogostuck: Rage With Your Friends
Worst Case Z
AckCon'18 - Lotter vs the World 2 - Preview Release
Evonet Beta v1.0 : Online Project Development Template
Who's Online
3 registered (AndrewAMD, jrath, OptimusPrime), 616 Guests and 8 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Newest Members
danatrader, ilikezorro, jibanes, nandv, cam1234
18187 Registered Users
Topic Options
Rate This Topic
#476188 - 02/03/19 17:49 not using profit targets during strategy development
gamadeus Offline
Newbie

Registered: 11/27/18
Posts: 40
In the presentation linked to the financial hacker it says:

"Do not use profittargets.(If you really want to, use a profit-lock mechanism instead)."

I have trouble understanding the argument. Im basically always using a TakeProfit when developing a trade system, particularly in the beginning when I evaluate entries.

Can somebody enlighten me what is meant here, maybe even jcl himself?

Top
#476193 - 02/03/19 21:12 Re: not using profit targets during strategy development [Re: gamadeus]
AndrewAMD Online
User

Registered: 02/21/17
Posts: 580
Loc: Chicago
Argument? This is largely learned through experience and data collection. Basically, profit targets limit the potential profit of any given trade and will tend to make your system less profitable.

This concept is examined in the book Trading Systems by Jaekle and Tomasini. It's definitely worth a read, especially for its coverage of risk management.

Why run some tests and see what it does to the profitability of your systems?

Top
#476194 - 02/03/19 22:16 Re: not using profit targets during strategy development [Re: AndrewAMD]
gamadeus Offline
Newbie

Registered: 11/27/18
Posts: 40
Well, I would hestitate to make that statement in general.

Certainly trend strategies get worse with a fixed TP but the same does not hold true for, say, a mean reverting strategy.

I know that book you recommended, and actually Profit Target is also discussed as an option when developing a system.



Edited by gamadeus (02/03/19 22:16)

Top
#476195 - 02/03/19 23:05 Re: not using profit targets during strategy development [Re: gamadeus]
AndrewAMD Online
User

Registered: 02/21/17
Posts: 580
Loc: Chicago
And you made MAE and MFE plots per the book’s suggestion? You can get a visual indication of whether or not take profit is appropriate.

Top
#476196 - 02/03/19 23:18 Re: not using profit targets during strategy development [Re: AndrewAMD]
gamadeus Offline
Newbie

Registered: 11/27/18
Posts: 40
Tbh I dont use MAE and MFE that much anymore. I think Zorro in combination with R features much better tools for analysis.

Anyway, I think you agree that there are systems where a TP might be appropriate. Which brings me back to my original question about that absolute statement in the presentation.
Perhaps that point is taken out of context, so it would be great if jcl could comment what that was all about.

Top
#476202 - 02/04/19 10:02 Re: not using profit targets during strategy development [Re: gamadeus]
jcl Offline

Chief Engineer

Registered: 07/22/00
Posts: 26783
Loc: Frankfurt
I do not know much situations where a TP would make sense. Suppose TP is at X and the price rises to maximum Y. If Y < X, the TP is useless. If Y > X, the TP causes a premature exit with loss of Y-X potential profit. Instead of a TP, you had then better used a profit lock or a tight trailing mechanism starting at X.

Top
#476203 - 02/04/19 10:09 Re: not using profit targets during strategy development [Re: jcl]
gamadeus Offline
Newbie

Registered: 11/27/18
Posts: 40
ok that makes sense, thanks. in my old MT days I had more luck with a TP than a trailing stop, but perhaps that was also due the limited possibilties I had with that plattform

are there any profit lock or trail settings that you would recommend to use as a starting point for strategy development?

Top
#476388 - 02/22/19 00:23 Re: not using profit targets during strategy development [Re: gamadeus]
laz Offline
Newbie

Registered: 01/20/19
Posts: 35
Loc: berlin
Feel free to read the last few notes (page 2) from my topic:

https://opserver.de/ubb7/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=476387&#Post476387

I asked something similar and learned a lot wink

Top



Gamestudio download | chip programmers | Zorro platform | shop | Data Protection Policy

oP group Germany GmbH | Birkenstr. 25-27 | 63549 Ronneburg / Germany | info (at) opgroup.de