Then man's will is greater than God's will. God desires that none should perish, but that all should come to repentance. However, man's free will sends the vast majority of people to hell. Since this choice was made by man's free will then it overshadowed the very will of God that none should perish.

Also, how did God foreknow who would select him and who would reject? If God looked down the corridors of time and saw who would accept, then that would indicate that there is something greater than God or something outside of God ... a fixed destiny that God had no control over. In other words, God was forced to accept the ones that accepted him and to reject the ones that rejected him. He was restricted and could not do otherwise.

The alternative is that God is the one that chose. If this is the case, then God decided that the vast majority of people will suffer eternally in hell (followed by the Lake of Fire) while only a select few from all of history will make it into eternal bliss.