but i still don't see an inconsistency. you're being inconsistent. first you're saying how it's wrong because it's black and white; now you're saying it's wrong because God actually takes the situation into account.

i can't at the moment think of a situation where it would be okay to kill someone. but if someone has one bullet in their gun and the only way you can save someone else's life is to put yourself between them and the bullet, you'd call that suicide, but of course it isn't a sin.

there's never good enough reason to sin. if something is the most righteous course of action you can take, you cannot call it a sin.

you think it's inconsistent? you don't believe in right and wrong?

julz