I'd go for the middle one, being a teen iN the 80's as I was.
But give him an eye-patch instead of shades, and a cobra chest-tattoo.
(Snake Pliskin from the "Escape from NY/LA" movies)

But honestly, seeing as there is no real storyline (if i remember correctly)
then why not have a character selection screen as game start.
Different character models that have NO impact on gameplay.

So you can choose Anit-Hero, Leather-clad chick, geek, whatever.
I'd love to see an Alice(from the resident-evil MOVIES) look-alike...