One vs. Two vs. Many

Print Thread

Rate Thread

Re: One vs. Two vs. Many [Re: fastlane69] #66703 03/15/06 16:31 03/15/06 16:31
Joined: Mar 2006 Posts: 54 A AndersA Junior Member
AndersA Junior Member A Joined: Mar 2006 Posts: 54	Quote: Quote: I know perfectly well what an axiom is and I still don't think your "god exists" axiom is useful for anything than stating that "something exists". You are missing the point then for that is the ONLY thing that axiom is meant to show: that something exists and then use that as a foundation for further investigation as to HOW MANY somethings there are[...] I think you're wrong and that my previous post should make perfect sense to someone versed in standard logic. Your "proof" is based on god being an object, but that is a way to strong conclusion to draw from the axiom "god exists". A reasonable interpretation of your axiom is that there is a predicate R(x) = "x has the property good" and that there exists at least one x for which R(x). In that language my first axiom A may be formally written as "(x)(y)(R(x) & R(y) --> x=y)". Last edited by AndersA; 03/15/06 16:34.

Entire Thread
Subject	Posted By	Posted
One vs. Two vs. Many	fastlane69	03/15/06 14:21
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	ROMAC	03/15/06 14:24
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	fastlane69	03/15/06 14:32
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	AndersA	03/15/06 14:46
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	fastlane69	03/15/06 14:55
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	jcl	03/15/06 15:21
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	fastlane69	03/15/06 19:01
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	Marco_Grubert	03/15/06 20:56
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	Scramasax	03/15/06 21:16
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	fastlane69	03/15/06 23:32
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	Marco_Grubert	03/16/06 01:05
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	fastlane69	03/16/06 02:57
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	AndersA	03/16/06 07:13
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	AndersA	03/15/06 23:00
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	AndersA	03/15/06 15:24
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	fastlane69	03/15/06 15:47
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	AndersA	03/15/06 16:31
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	ICEman	03/15/06 16:55
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	AndersA	03/15/06 18:26
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	fastlane69	03/15/06 18:58
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	AndersA	03/15/06 22:51
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	fastlane69	03/15/06 23:43
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	ICEman	03/16/06 00:42
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	AndersA	03/16/06 07:28
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	fastlane69	03/16/06 14:47
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	AndersA	03/16/06 17:11
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	fastlane69	03/16/06 17:39
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	AndersA	03/16/06 19:10
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	fastlane69	03/16/06 20:09
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	Matt_Aufderheide	03/16/06 20:38
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	AndersA	03/16/06 23:31
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	fastlane69	03/17/06 00:44
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	Matt_Aufderheide	03/17/06 07:47
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	fastlane69	03/17/06 15:36
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	Matt_Aufderheide	03/17/06 21:11
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	NITRO777	03/17/06 21:29
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	fastlane69	03/17/06 22:03
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	Matt_Aufderheide	03/17/06 22:28
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	NITRO777	03/17/06 23:06
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	NITRO777	03/17/06 23:41
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	Matt_Aufderheide	03/17/06 23:55
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	NITRO777	03/18/06 00:08
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	mpdeveloper_B	03/18/06 04:23
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	ICEman	03/18/06 04:40
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	Matt_Aufderheide	03/18/06 06:37
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	NITRO777	03/18/06 13:36
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	Scramasax	03/18/06 19:58
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	mpdeveloper_B	03/19/06 00:04
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	Grimber	03/17/06 22:18
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	Anonymous	10/01/06 11:20
Re: One vs. Two vs. Many	Alberto	10/01/06 12:32

Moderated by jcl, Lukas, old_bill, Spirit