Quote:

I think what he is saying is that, assuming that God(s) exist as the given for this discussion (which means that you will have a hard time stomaching this discussion and an even harder time contributing if you dont believe in one at all)


You may be right and you probably are, but in that case it's strange that he wants this discussion to from the point of view of science and/or logic.

I have given him a perfectly reasonable logic answer and natural science is simply not about religion of any kind so I really don't see why he isn't happy with my answer