'newbie' ' my first...' forum not needed IMO. Showcase 1 and showcase 2 should just be re designated..... SC1 for 'give me feedback on this...' like topics, SC2 to show off actual WIP projects..

Redesignating the SC1 and SC2 then you could also resolve the Selling/Contribution debate and put For Sale in showcase2 since sellign items would be showcasing a final product, not contributing them

also adding another forum will just add to the '.. not moderated enough...'